Baseball Digest Pitcher of the Year Award

Baseball Digest began its coverage of Major League Baseball in August 1942. They are, in Baseball Almanac's opinion, the single best source of baseball information anywhere. Player profiles, official rosters, schedules, scouting reports, and articles that are in a class by themselves are what you are missing if you do not receive Baseball Digest in your mailbox every month!

Listed below in chronological order are the pitchers chosen by Baseball Digest as recipients of Baseball Digest's Pitcher of the Year. Pitchers were included in Player of the Year selections through 1993. In 1994 Baseball Digest began choosing both a Player & Pitcher of the Year.

"The pitcher is the one player who can dominate and take control of game." - Bob Kuenster in Baseball Digest (January 2002)
Baseball Digest's Pitcher of the Year Award

In Chronological Order / Baseball Digest Player of the Year Award

Year

Pitcher (Quantity)

Team

Throws

Baseball Digest Notes / Reason

1994

Greg Maddux (1)

Braves

R

Strike-shortened season went 16-6 with 1.56 ERA.

1995

Greg Maddux (2)

Braves

R

Posted .905 win percentage (19-2) with 1.63 ERA.

1996

John Smoltz (1)

Braves

R

Fanned 276 batters with 24.8 mark and 2.94 ERA.

1997

Roger Clemens (1)

Blue Jays

R

Led AL in wins (21), ERA (2.05) & strikeouts (292).

1998

Kevin Brown (1)

Padres

R

Paced Padres to pennant 18 wins, 2.83 ERA, 257Ks.

1999

Pedro Martinez (1)

Red Sox

R

Won 23 games with 2.07 ERA and 313 strikeouts.

2000

Pedro Martinez (2)

Red Sox

R

Went 18-6 with 284 whiffs and league-low 1.74 ERA.

2001

Curt Schilling (1)

Diamondbacks

R

Topped majors with 22 wins to go with 293 Ks.

2002

Randy Johnson (1)

Diamondbacks

L

Led NL in wins (24), ERA (2.32) & strikeouts (334).

2003

Roy Halladay (1)

Blue Jays

R

Threw 9 complete games, 2 shutouts & won 22.

2004

Curt Schilling (2)

Red Sox

R

Started #2, took lead, and helped reverse the curse.

2005

Dontrelle Willis (1)

Marlins

L

22-10, 2.63 ERA, 5 shutouts, 170 Ks, 55 walks.

2006

Johan Santana (1)

Twins

L

Led majors in wins (19), strikeouts (245) & ERA (2.77).

2007

Josh Beckett (1)

Red Sox

R

Helped win World Series title & only 20 game winner.

2008

Cliff Lee (1)

Indians

L

Won 22 of 31 starts, ERA champ & struckout 170.

2009 Zack Greinke (1) Royals R Major League low ERA (2.16) with 16 wins & 242 Ks.
2010 Roy Halladay (1) Phillies R Perfect Game, led wins, complete games & shutouts.
2011 Justin Verlander (1) Tigers R Won Triple Crown, led majors in wins & strikeouts.

2012

Not Yet Announced (12-2012)

--

--

--

Year

Pitcher (Quantity)

Team

Throws

Baseball Digest Notes / Reason

Baseball Digest's Pitcher of the Year Winners | Bold=Cy Young Award Winner.



Do you agree or disagree with Baseball Digest's winners? How about their top twelve starting pitchers for the 2001 season (below)? Take a moment and share your thoughts with fellow fans on our baseball message boards.

The Nasty Dozen (Baseball Digest January 2002) article appeared in the same issue and ranked the top twelve (12) starting pitchers of the 2001 season. They were, in reverse order: 12. Mark Buehrle, 11. Tim Hudson, 10. Jon Lieber, 9. Javier Vazquez, 8. Mark Mulder, 7. Matt Morris, 6. Freddy Garcia, 5. Greg Maddux, 4. Roger Clemens, 3. Mike Mussina, 2. Randy Johnson, and 1. Curt Schilling.

Baseball Digest selects the recipient of the Pitcher of the Year Award based on who was "the most complete and dominant starting pitcher over the course of the season." To qualify alone requires that the pitcher has won at least fifteen games, pitcher 200+ innings, and have an ERA below 4.00.

Baseball Almanac on Facebook

Google
Web baseball-almanac.com