% of Votes

Hunter's All-Star Catch

31%

Giambi's Grand Slam

26%

Tejada's Game-Winning HR

16%

Berkman's on the Hill Catch

14%

Long Robs Ramirez

13%

% of Votes

Grace the Ace

50%

Piniella Gets Tossed

22%

Millar Takes a Dive

10%

Miscues of Jason Lane

9%

Announcer Call It Like He Sees It

9%

Team

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

John Smoltz

Atlanta

This Year in Baseball Awards

Team

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

Mark Prior

Chicago

2003 Play of the Year Award

% of Votes

Furcal Unassisted Triple Play

19.5%

Matsui's Grand Slam

13.0%

Edmond's Catch

12.4%

Bonds' Homer

10.5%

Giles Robs Homer

10.1%

Boone's Catch and Flip

7.6%

2003 Individual Performance of the Year Award

% of Votes

Mueller First Grand Slams Both Side of Plate

34.0%

Damon's 3 Hits in an Inning

23.4%

Delgado's Four Homers

11.9%

Millwood's No-Hitter

9.4%

Byrnes Hitting for the Cycle

5.8%

Willis' One-Hitter

4.9%

2003 Bizarre Moment of the Year Award

% of Votes

Ozzy Osbourne Sings Take Me Out to the Ballgame

17.9%

Cust Falling Down

15.4%

Very Lucky Fan

13.8%

Misspelled Angels

13.0%

Infield Fly RBI

11.4%

Snow-ball Flight

10.1%

This Year in Baseball Awards

Team

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

Johan Santana

Minnesota

2004 Individual Performance of the Year Award

% of Votes

40-Year old Johnson Tosses Perfect Game

52.4%

Pujols Has 3 Home Runs & 5 RBIs

13.3%

Vlad Hits 9 RBIs in a Game

9.5%

Sheets Strikes out 18

4.8%

Mackowiak Walk-Off Grand Slam

4.7%

2004 Play of the Year Award

% of Votes

Jeter Catch in the Stands

31.8%

Mueller Sinks Yanks with 9th Inning HR

13.5%

Ramirez Robs Cairo of a HR

11.2%

Edmonds Steals a homer in the 9th

9.9%

Finley's Grand Slam Clinches NL West

8.1%

2004 Blooper of the Year Award

% of Votes

Michaels Bobbles HR

22.7%

Manny Cuts off Damon

17.6%

Squirrel Invades Field

17.0%

Crisp and Duque Dance

11.9%

Fan Makes a Catch in Cup

11.5%

2005 Individual Performance of the Year Award

% of Votes

Alex Rodriguez 3 HR & 10 RBI Game

42.1%

Chris Carpenter 1-Hitter

14.1%

Ryan Freel 3-4 & Team Record 5 Steals in 1 Game

8.5%

Mark Grudzielanek Hitting for the Cycle

8.0%

Randy Winn Hitting for the Cycle

7.9%

This Year in Baseball Awards

Team

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

Chris Carpenter

St. Louis

2005 Blooper of the Year Award

% of Votes

Pedro Gets Soaked

25.3%

K-Rod Misses the Ball

21.5%

Twin Trio of Errors

11.4%

Cordero Bounces it In

10.4%

Security Guard Interference

9.8%

2005 Play of the Year Award

% of Votes

Wright's Barehander

32.8%

Jeter's Catch

13.6%

Linden's Catch

7.8%

Eckstein's Walk-Off Slam

5.9%

Ichiro's Amazing Grab

4.6%

Endy Chavez: Robs Rolen of home run

30.0%

Magglio Ordonez: Home runs win AL pennant

19.4%

Yadier Molina: Game 7, NLCS homer gives Cards lead

15.5%

Adam Wainwright: Game 7, NLCS Beltran k, NL pennant

11.0%

Paul Lo Duca: Game 1, NLDS Tags out two at home

8.4%

David Eckstein: Game 4 WS double puts Cards ahead

5.9%

Adam Wainwright: Game 5 WS, Inge k wins Series

5.5%

Mark Kotsay: Game 2 ALDS, inside the park homer

4.5%

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

Chien-Ming Wang

New York

NYY: Melky Cabrera robs Manny Ramirez

14.0%

TEX: Gary Matthews, Jr. goes above and beyond

11.0%

BOS: Mike Lowell dives into crowd

7.4%

PHI: Aaron Rowand runs into fence

7.0%

MIN: Twins turn into triple play

6.9%

SLN: Scott Rolen displays airtight 'D'

6.7%

NYM: Carlos Beltran robs Lance Berkman

6.4%

CHA: Tadahito Iguchi defies gravity

6.3%

DET: Brandon Inge makes backhanded grab

4.1%

ATL: Andruw Jones brings back homer

2.6%

SEA: Ichiro Suzuki fires laser to home

2.4%

CIN: Ryan Freel robs Albert Pujols

2.3%

SFN: Omar Vizquel turns heads-up DP

2.1%

HOU: Willy Taveras displays dominant 'D'

2.0%

TAM: Rays turn historic triple play

1.9%

CHI: Juan Pierre robs Albert Pujols

1.8%

CLE: Grady Sizemore lays out

1.7%

OAK: Barry Zito goes behind the back

1.7%

MIL: Bill Hall delivers Mays-like grab

1.4%

SDN: Khalil Greene starts sweet DP

1.4%

BAL: Corey Patterson holds on

1.3%

LAN: Greg Maddux snares liner

1.2%

LAA: Juan Rivera nails Mark Kotsay at home

1.2%

TOR: Eric Hinske flies to make game-ending grab

1.1%

COL: Brad Hawpe displays arm strength

1.0%

KCR: Middle men turn spectacular DP

0.8%

WAS: Ryan Zimmerman snags tough pop

0.7%

PIT: Freddy Sanchez snags foul pop

0.6%

ARI: Eric Byrnes, Johnny Estrada deny Jamey Carroll

0.5%

FLO: Diving Miguel Cabrera flashes leather

0.5%

Sean Casey: Casey thrown out on sure-fire single

38.1%

Andruw Jones: Andruw floored over homer

24.8%

Giants Balldude: Balldude wins battle for ball

16.4%

President Race: Thomas Jefferson bites the dust

8.3%

Jeter and A-Rod: Yanks' duo flubs easy fly out

5.4%

Reggie Sanders: Big swing leads to sanders' stumble

3.6%

Giles and Walker: Padres pair teams up on bobbled ball

1.8%

Rios and Cora: Rios gives away Red Sox homer

1.8%

Albert Pujols

3-4, 3HR (walk off), 5RBI

26.7%

Anibal Sanchez

No Hitter

25.4%

Ryan Howard

4-4, 3 HR, 4 RBI

13.0%

Dontrelle Willis

3-4, 2 HR & 8.1 IP

12.0%

James Loney

4-5, 2HR, 9RBI

5.0%

John Lackey

1-Hitter

4.9%

Carl Crawford

5-5, HR, 5 R, 4SB

3.5%

Gary Matthews, Jr.

Hit fo the Cycle

3.3%

Marlon Anderson

5-5, 3B, 2HR, SB

3.2%

Jason Schmidt

CG, 7 H, 16K's

3.0%

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

Boston

2008 This Year in Baseball Awards

Winner

Team

Starting Pitcher of the Year Award

2009 This Year in Baseball Awards

Winner

Team

Setup Man of the Year Award

San Francisco

2010 This Year in Baseball Awards

Winner

Team

Setup Man of the Year Award

2011 This Year in Baseball Awards

Winner

Team

--

Setup Man of the Year Award

--

This Year in Baseball Award

Winner

Team

This Year in Baseball Awards