Billy Evans Obituary

Baseball Almanac presents the actual word-for-word transcript from the obituary of umpire Billy Evans, taken from and courtesy of The New York Times.

"Well, it would have been a fair ball yesterday and it will be fair tomorrow and for all years to come. But right now, unfortunately, it's foul because that's the way I called it." - Billy Evans

Billy Evans Obituary

Appeared in The New York Times on January 24, 1956

Billy Evans Obituary

Billy Evans Dies in Miami at 71;
Major League Umpire 22 Years


MIAMI, Fla., Jan. 23 (AP) — William George (Billy) Evans, widely known baseball executive and formerly an American League umpire for twenty-two years, died tonight in North Shore Hospital. He was 71 years old.

Mr. Evans, who was visiting his son here, suffered a stroke last Saturday and was taken to the hospital at that time.

Mr. Evans was born in Chicago on Feb. 10, 1884. He played college football and also played baseball in some semi-professional leagues, but never played the game as a professional.

Mr. Evans did considerable writing and, for a time, operated his own syndicate. He also contributed to national magazines.

Mr. Evans, who made his home in Cleveland, had come to Miami with his wife two weeks ago to visit their son, Robert B. Evans, sports director of radio station WKAT.


Noted for Commentaries

Billy Evans was noted for his pithy commentaries on the umpire-player relationship.

He summed it all up once when, after shouting, "Foul ball!" the ball in question hit a pebble and rolled fair. In response to howls of wrath from the dugout of the team at bat, Mr. Evans said: "Well, it would have been a fair ball yesterday and it will be fair tomorrow and for all years to come. But right now, unfortunately, it's foul because that's the way I called it."

What his statement amounted to was an admission that, although an umpire cannot always be right, he must stick by his decision.

Mr. Evans studied at Cornell University. However, he left before graduating and took a $15-a-week job as a sports reported for The Youngstown (Ohio) Vindicator.

While reported a baseball game in the Class D Ohio-Pennsylvania League in 1904, Mr. Evans was drafted to fill an umpiring vacancy. He did the job well and was hired as a regular at $15 a game. Two years later, he was called upon to work for the American League. He was said to have been the only major league umpire who never had played professional baseball himself.

For twenty-two years he was one of the outstanding umpires in the junior circuit, and was rated as a master of the diplomatic, rather than the belligerent solution to the perennial "rhubarb."

Mr. Evans retired from umpiring in 1928 to become general manager of the Cleveland Indians. The club finished in the first division in seven of the eight seasons he was with it. He went to the Boston Red Sox in 1936, and served until 1941 as director of its minor league clubs: It was at his suggestion that the Red Sox bought the Louisville club of the American Association, primarily to acquire the services of Harold (Peewee) Reese. The Red Sox, however, let Mr. Reese slip away to Brooklyn.

After a term as general manager of the former Cleveland Rams of the National Football League, Mr. Evans became president of the Southern Association in 1943. In 1946, be became executive vice president and general manager of the Detroit Tigers. He resigned this post in July, 1951.

Billy Evans Obituary



Billy Evans — described above as a "master of the diplomatic" —once had an actual fist fight with Ty Cobb! Former major leaguer / "Crown Price of Baseball" Al Schacht described the incident, "When the game ended they both went under the grandstand while the members of both teams became spectators. Billy posed like a real fighter while Ty stalked him like a Tiger and then suddenly hit him in the jaw. Down went Evans with Ty on top of him. With his knee on Evans' chest, Ty held Billy by the throat and tried to choke him. We finally got him off Billy and that was the end of the fight."

Billy Evans was elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame by the Committee on Baseball Veterans on January 28, 1973. His hall of fame plaque reads as follows:

WILLIAM GEORGE EVANS
UMPIRE AND EXECUTIVE
EMPLOYED BY AMERICAN LEAGUE IN
1906 AT AGE 22, MAKING HIM YOUNGEST
UMPIRE EVER IN MAJORS. SERVED ON A.L.
STAFF THROUGH 1927. OFFICIATED IN
SIX WORLD SERIES. GENERAL MANAGER
OF CLEVELAND INDIANS, 1927-1935, FARM
DIRECTOR OF BOSTON RED SOX 1936-1940
PRESIDENT OF SOUTHERN ASSOCIATION,
1942-1946. GENERAL MANAGER OF
DETROIT TIGERS, 1947-1951.

Did you know that Billy Evans joined the American League at the age of twenty-two (22) — the youngest umpire in the major leagues and the only one ever promoted from Class C ball?