The 1994 strike set in motion a chain of events that Major League Baseball and its fans still feels to this day. One of them was the use of replacement players during Spring Training in 1995 (Excel spreadsheet with complete rosters can be download from this page). These players, like them or not, crossed the proverbial picket line and became forever known as the replacements.
Each of the players below, according to the Players Association, are not allowed union membership. They each are given representation during arbitration or other matters, they all receive pension benefits, but they are not part of the actual union — which essentially means they do not receive any licensing monies and they cannot vote on union matters.
Each Major League team was permitted to carry thirty-two replacement players on their rosters for Opening Day and twenty-five could be used in any game. No waivers were going to be used, no disabled lists, and salaries were set at $115,000 (plus a $5,000 signing bonus, a $5,000 bonus for making the Opening Day roster, and up to three players could have a contract as high as $275,000).
When the strike finally came to an end, Major League players had a three week Spring Training and replacement players were either sent to the Minor Leagues, terminated, or in some cases given a team travel bag to load their belongings in before leaving to their homes. However, the following players have made it to "the majors" and are considered non-union replacement players.
Note: The American Professional Baseball Association (APBA) is a baseball simulation board game, created in 1951, and the predecessor to Strat-O-Matic. The cards used in 1994 and 1995 included the replacement players, but used "fake names" which are included below, just for those seeking trivial "research" not found anywhere else.
"It was one of the lowest points in baseball history, a time of anger, confusion and disgrace. In spring training of 1995, major league players were on strike, so teams were built with replacement players, a collection of minor leaguers, former major leaguers and anyone else who could play at all." - Kurkjian, Tim. ESPN The Magazine. August 2002.
Replacement PlayersIn Alphabetical Order |
||
Replacement Players | Debut | Box | APBA™ Fake Name |
Joel Adamson | 04-10-1996 | Levi Atwater |
Benny Agbayani | 06-17-1998 | Brian Hiller |
Tony Barron | 06-02-1996 | Jim Ripp |
Mike Busch | 09-30-1995 | Real Name Used |
Joe Crawford | 04-07-1997 | Randy Gaynes |
Brian Daubach | 09-10-1998 | Jack Harten |
Brendan Donnelly | 04-09-2002 | Real Name Used |
Angel Echevarria | 07-15-1996 | Andy Gabriel |
Charles Gipson | 03-31-1998 | Fred Rivers |
Scarborough Green | 08-02-1997 | Rey Clem |
Jason Hardtke | 09-08-1996 | Robbie Miller |
Pep Harris | 08-14-1996 | Lancaster St. James |
Matt Herges | 08-03-1999 | Keith Shetter |
Chris Latham | 04-12-1997 | Joey Laker |
Cory Lidle | 05-08-1997 | Fuller Starr |
Kerry Ligtenberg | 08-12-1997 | Lee Grove |
Rich Loiselle | 09-07-1996 | Frankie Nina |
Ron Mahay | 05-21-1995 | Red Crestwood |
Tom Martin | 04-02-1997 | Eddie Chamura |
Walt McKeel | 09-14-1996 | Real Name Used |
Frank Menechino | 09-07-1999 | Jerry Legler |
Lou Merloni | 05-10-1998 | Joey DePalma |
Kevin Millar | 04-11-1998 | Mike Butcher |
Damian Miller | 08-10-1997 | Don Cross |
Eddie Oropesa | 04-02-2001 | Real Name Used |
Keith Osik | 04-05-1996 | Rollie Thomas |
Bronswell Patrick | 05-18-1998 | Charles Dempsey |
Alex Ramirez | 09-19-1998 | Doug Mast |
Mandy Romero | 07-15-1997 | Barry Armand |
Chuck Smith | 06-13-2000 | Tom Keaton |
Shane Spencer | 04-10-1998 | Jimmy Ladd |
Joe Strong | 05-11-2000 | Dan Ruth |
Pedro Swann | 09-09-2000 | Real Name Used |
Jeff Tam | 06-03-1998 | Todd Pearl |
Brian Tollberg | 06-20-2000 | Norm Heffner |
Chris Truby | 06-16-2000 | Sonny Young |
Jamie Walker | 04-02-1997 | Rey Clark |
Replacement Players | Debut | Box | APBA™ Fake Name |
Replacement Players With MLB ExperienceIn Alphabetical Order |
||
Replacement Players | Debut | Box | APBA™ Fake Name |
Pedro Borbon * | 04-09-1969 | Real Name Used |
Wayne Edwards | 09-11-1989 | Real Name Used |
Tom McCarthy | 07-05-1985 | Real Name Used |
Rafael Montalvo | 04-13-1986 | Real Name Used |
Rick Reed ** | 08-08-1988 | Alan Hunt |
Joe Slusarski | 04-11-1991 | Bob Bleacher |
Replacement Players | Debut | Box | APBA™ Fake Name |
Replacement Players | Research by Baseball Almanac | ||
Sources : The Cultural Encyclopedia of Baseball (1999) : New York Times (Many Citations from 1994) : Line Drives Newsletter [Dodgers] (May 1995) : David A. Walker [APBA Data] (08-01-2004) : Jason Robertson [Excel Data] (08-31-2004) |
The replacement players were entitled to their signing bonus and Spring Training expenses. Most of the Major League teams paid this and gave a severance ranging from $2,000 to $5,000 per player. The St. Louis Cardinals, on the other hand, gave each replacement player $25,000 while the Montreal Expos gave each player a jersey. The Phillies, who probably did not want to be considered as cheap as the Expos, gave each player their jersey AND a ball signed by the entire team (the same team that they were playing on / with).
Click Computer to Download Spring 1995 Excel Data
How do you feel about replacement players? Should current / modern players still hold a grudge? Should the players listed above be allowed into the union? Share your opinion on Baseball Fever today, but keep in mind some of the situations each player was placed in during that particular time:
(*) Pedro Borbon had not played in the majors since 1980, but crossed the picket line to play again. The New York Times explained, "He became part of baseball lore in 1995 when, at age 48, he decided to return to the game as a replacement player during Major League Baseball’s labor dispute. He struck out the only batter he faced in an exhibition against the Pirates in Bradenton, Fla. But the Reds released him after he faced one batter in a game against the Indians, fell down while trying to field a bunt and threw wildly to first base for an error."
(**) Tim Kurkjian in ESPN The Magazine wrote, "Rick Reed knew. He was pitching for the Reds' Triple-A club, his 10th year of pro ball. He was told by the Reds to cross the line or he'd be released, then blackballed. Reed's mother was sick, he was paying her medical bills, and he couldn't stop working. So he played. Late in the 1995 season, he was recalled by the Reds because they badly needed pitching. General manager Jim Bowden called a team meeting to inform the players of what he was planning to do. One player stood up in the back of the clubhouse and screamed his opposition, claiming he would never be a teammate with a 'scab.' "
The Cultural Encyclopedia of Baseball (1996) reported that, "A player making the Major League average of $1.2 million lost $355,776 in salary during the 1994 portion of the strike ($6,976 per day)."