Error Records by Catchers

Baseball Almanac invites you to examine error records by catchers. Research is complete through completion of the previous season and includes all of the possible error record variations.

"You're always happy to hit a home run. It doesn't matter where it goes, or how far." - Florida Marlins Catcher Charles Johnson (Associated Press, 10/19/1997, 'Johnson's bat becomes bonus for Marlins')
Errors by Catchers

Career Records

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Most
In A Career

AL

Wally Schang

Philadelphia

67

218 Total

Boston

40

New York

65

St. Louis

26

Detroit

20

NL

Ivey Wingo

St. Louis

59

234 Total

Cincinnati

175

Most Consecutive Games
Without An Error in a Career

AL Mike Redmond

Minnesota (218)

232

04-06-2005

Cleveland (14)

05-18-2010

NL

Mike Matheny

St. Louis

252

08-02-2002
St. Louis 08-01-2004
ML Mike Redmond

Florida (21)

253

07-22-2004

Minnesota (218) Thru

Cleveland (14)

05-18-2010

Most Seasons
Leading The League in a Career

AL

Birdie Tebbetts

Detroit

6

1939 (16)

Detroit

1940 (17)

Detroit

1942 (12)

Detroit / Boston

1947 (10)

Boston

1948 (10)

Boston

1949 (11)

NL

Ivey Wingo

St. Louis

7

1912 (23)

St. Louis

1913 (28)

Cincinnati

1916 (28)

Cincinnati

1917 (21)

Cincinnati

1918 (12)

Cincinnati

1920 (21)

Cincinnati

1921 (18)

Errors by Catchers

Single Season Records

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Fewest
In A Season
100+ Games Caught

AL

Buddy Rosar

Philadelphia

0

1946

NL Charles Johnson Florida

0

1997
Mike Matheny

St. Louis

2003

Fewest
In A Season
150+ Games Caught

AL

Jim Sundberg

Texas

4

1979

NL

Randy Hundley

Chicago

4

1967

Fewest
In A Season
By The League Leader

AL

Rick Ferrell

St. Louis

7

1933

NL

Hank Foiles

Pittsburgh

9

1957

Most
In A Season

AL

Oscar Stanage

Detroit

41

1911

NL

Nat Hicks

New York

94

1876

Most Consecutive Games
Without An Error in a Season

AL

A.J. Pierzynski

Chicago

117

04-19-2005
10-02-2005
Buddy Rosar Philadelphia

04-16-1946

09-29-1946

NL

Mike Matheny

St. Louis

138

03-31-2003

09-28-2003

Errors by Catchers

Game Records

Record

Lg

Name(s)

Team(s)

Data

Most
In A Game

AL

Bill Moore

Boston

4

09-26-1927

John Peters

Cleveland

05-16-1918

Lena Styles

Philadelphia

07-29-1921

NL

Dick Lowe

Detroit

7

06-26-1884

Jack Rowe

Buffalo

05-16-1883

Most
In An Inning

AL

John Peters

Cleveland

3

05-16-1918

1st Inning

Ed Sweeney

New York

07-10-1912

1st Inning

NL

Doggie Miller

St. Louis

4

05-24-1895

2nd Inning

Record Lg Name(s) Team(s) Data

Pinch Hitters / Pinch Hitting Records



On April 22, 1932, Frankie Pytlak of the Cleveland Indians caught his first Major League game and did not commit an error until his ninety-fourth game setting a record for most consecutive errorless games caught from the start of a Major League career.

Jerry Grote (April 15, 1968), Doc Powers (September 1, 1906), Buddy Rosar (July 21, 1945), Bob Swift (July 21, 1945), and Hal King (April 15, 1968) have each participated in a twenty-four inning game at catcher without committing a single error tieing each other for longest game caught in Major League history without an error by the catcher.

Consecutive chances accepted by a catcher without an error have also been researched and Charles Johnson of the Florida Marlins holds the Major League record for most consecutive chances without an error in a season with nine-hundred seventy-three in 1997 and Mike Matheny of the St. Louis Cardinals holds the Major League record for most consecutive chances without an error over the course of a career with one-thousand five-hundred sixty-five (August 2, 2002 through August 1, 2004).

     

Baseball Almanac on Facebook